The Index
Ranked. Averaged. Argued over.
Every steakhouse the Council has sat down at, ordered by score. Disagreements welcome; recounts are not. Compare any two side by side →
4 of 4 restaurants
RankRestaurantLocationTierReviewersScore
1Gallagher's SteakhouseFull reviewMidtown, Manhattan · 4 reviewersMidtownManhattanExceptional42Delmonico'sFull reviewFinancial District, Manhattan · 5 reviewersFinancial DistrictManhattanExcellent53Harry'sFull reviewFinancial District, Manhattan · 3 reviewersFinancial DistrictManhattanVery Good34Peter Luger Steak HouseFull reviewWilliamsburg, Brooklyn · 4 reviewersWilliamsburgBrooklynVery Good4
Browse by neighborhood
On the map.
Every ranked steakhouse, with its official Council score. The map follows your search and filters above.
Loading the map…